The Unconventional Jingle: Exploring the Charms of Indie Rock Holiday Songs

The holiday season is traditionally accompanied by the familiar sounds of sleigh bells, cheerful choirs, and iconic tunes from well-established artists. However, for those with an inclination towards alternative and independent music, the indie rock genre offers a refreshing twist to the festive soundtrack. On November 21st, Tom Gilliam and I celebrated our 13th annual YTAA Indie Holiday show. We played music from Dolph Chaney, The Popravinas, The Ramones, The Pogues, Darling West, Heather Redman, Fitz and The Tantrums, My Morning Jacket, Van Plating, Olivia Frances, The Surfajettes, Best Coast, Trey Stone and The Ringers, Calexico, Librarians with Hickeys, Debra Devi, Fountains of Wayne, The Decemberists, Joey Ramone, Bad Religion, Heartless Bastards, The Killers, and Dayton’s own Escape Velocity among others over three hours. I wanted to publicly thank Tom Gilliam of the excellent Dayton-based band Ghost Town Silence, for doing this special show with me for over a decade. I wondered what is it about independent music that allows for the creation of exciting new holiday music. So, if you will indulge me as we enter the holiday season, I will delve into the world of indie rock holiday songs, exploring the charm and uniqueness they bring to the season.

Taking a break from tradition can be a healthy and positive experience. Indie rock holiday songs provide a welcome departure from the conventional jingles and carols that dominate the airwaves during the festive season. Unlike the predictability of traditional holiday music, indie rock artists infuse their creativity into the lyrics and melodies, offering a fresh and sometimes irreverent take on the holiday spirit. The departure from traditional sounds allows listeners to experience the season with a new perspective, embracing the diversity that indie rock brings to the table.

One of the hallmarks of indie rock is its ability to convey complex emotions through music, expressing complex emotions — that special sense of being hit “in the feels” can be a moment of self-reflection. While traditional holiday songs often focus on joy and celebration, indie rock holiday tunes explore a broader spectrum of feelings associated with the season. From the melancholic reflections on solitude during the holidays to the bittersweet nostalgia of past celebrations, indie rock captures the multifaceted nature of the holiday experience. Artists like Sufjan Stevens, The Shins, Debra Devi, and Heartless Bastards weave intricate narratives that resonate with those who may find the holiday season to be a mix of joy and introspection. The Decemberists’ reinterpretation of Big Star’s Jesus Christ, from their album 3rd released in 1974, illustrates this approach quite clearly. The band’s official video incorporates the idea of a Yule Log experience into the music video.

Indie rock holiday songs showcase a range of perspectives on the holidays, reflecting the diversity of experiences within the indie rock community. One of the great aspects of alternative and independent music is the opening to diverse perspectives on the holidays. These songs often touch upon themes like non-traditional celebrations, unconventional family dynamics, and the challenges of navigating societal expectations during the festive season. The narratives presented in indie rock holiday songs provide a sense of relatability for listeners who may not find their own experiences mirrored in more mainstream holiday music. The 2016 original holiday song, “I Feel It In My Bones” from The Killers’ alternative holiday album “Don’t Waste Your Wishes” takes a dark, almost sinister interpretation of Santa Claus.

Indie rock, by its very nature, is a genre that thrives on experimentation and innovation. The best characteristic of an independent song is the surprise you discover when you hear it. Dolph Chaney’s excellent “Jingle Bells” set to Van Halen’s “Panama” is a complete surprise as well as a delight! Big Stir Records has released several fantastic indie holiday songs as part of their Yuletide Wave. When applied to holiday music, the willingness to explore and recreate results in a rich tapestry of unique soundscapes in which to capture the seasonal vibe. From the indie alt-country and folk-infused sounds of Trey Stones and The Ringers’ “Santa, Please Bring Me a Guitar” to the rock and roll vibes of The Ramones “Merry Christmas (I Don’t Want to Fight Tonight),” these songs reimagine the sonic landscape of the holidays. The infusion of indie rock elements into holiday music introduces listeners to a sonic experience that goes beyond the traditional, breathing new life into the seasonal soundscape.

Indie rock holiday songs offer a delightful departure from the familiar tunes that dominate the airwaves during the festive season. By expressing complex emotions, presenting diverse perspectives, and exploring unique soundscapes, indie rock artists contribute a distinct flavor to the holiday music repertoire. The unconventional jingles and alternative carols provide an avenue for listeners to connect with the holiday spirit in ways that resonate with the ever-evolving nature of contemporary music. So, this holiday season, consider expanding your playlist to include indie rock gems that bring a touch of creativity and innovation to the festive sounds we hear this time of year.

Heather Redman & The Reputation: A Funky Soulful-Blues Infused Rock Odyssey

In the ever-evolving kaleidoscope of rock and blues, it’s rare to come across a band that can channel the raw essence of classic genres while injecting a fresh and exhilarating spirit into their music. Enter Heather Redman & The Reputation, a group of fantastic Dayton, Ohio musicians whose debut album is nothing short of a revelation in the world of contemporary rock and roll. If you’re craving the kind of music that grabs you by the soul and refuses to let go, then look no further. This is Heather Redman & The Reputation, and their self-titled album is a tour de force of funky soulful blues-infused rock that takes you on a journey through love, pain, longing, and everything in between.

Heather Redman’s husky, soulful voice immediately captivates the listener, drawing them into the world of her lyrics. The Reputation’s instrumentation serves as the perfect backdrop to Redman’s compelling storytelling, creating a synergy that is seldom encountered in modern music. Their self-titled album takes you on a mesmerizing musical journey, exploring a variety of emotional landscapes through a potent blend of soul, blues, rock, and blues influences.

The opening track, “Everybody,” sets the tone for the entire album. Redman’s voice takes center stage, conveying the emotional depth of the lyrics. It’s a heartfelt tour-de-force ode to community where all are welcome, with a bluesy, slow-tempo groove that pulls you in and doesn’t let go for a single second. The vocals are exceptional. Whether she whispers or screams, Redman sings with unrestrained passion that would destroy a lesser singer. I would pay money to hear Heather Redman sing the phonebook. The guitar work courtesy of Matt Webster on this track is exceptional, capturing the essence of classic soulful blues while adding a modern flair. The keyboards feel like they are dancing around the room. The percussion propels the song forward so well that you are a bit surprised when the song ends. It’s a tantalizing preview of what’s to come.

As the album progresses, “Step Back Girl” showcases Heather Redman’s songwriting prowess. The lyrics are poignant and fun, painting a picture of flirtation, fascination, and being a little star-struck. The Reputation’s musicianship is on full display, with a jangly guitar that adds a layer of emotional depth to the song. This track is a testament to the band’s ability to convey complex emotions through their music without talking down to their audience. There is a wink that the object of affection may be important to the narrator of the song as well as the young lady filled with longing watching the desired musician up on stage.

The album takes a turn with “Wait For Me,” a high-energy track that fuses rock with blues in an electrifying way. Redman’s voice soars, showing her versatility as a vocalist. The Reputation’s rhythm section locks into a tight groove, propelling the song forward with an infectious energy. “Wait For Me” is a stand-out track that demonstrates the band’s ability to switch between different moods and styles seamlessly. This song swirls from the start of the organ to the punch of the chorus with a beautiful harmonic blending of voices and emotions. The song captures the pushes and pulls of hope, desire, and the slow realization that we are all waiting.

One of the defining qualities of this album is its lyrical depth and swirling maelstrom of musical inventiveness. “Daydream” is a prime example, a song that seems to delve into themes of reflection and regret. Redman’s lyrical delivery is passionate and introspective at the same time, and the band’s movement is at times restrained and in other moments goes full bore like their lives depend on it. The instrumentation provides the perfect canvas for Heather Redman to paint her emotional narrative. The use of horns in this track is a beautiful touch, adding to the overall quality of the song.

The album reaches its climax with the Salvadore Ross cover of “Broken Bones,” a mesmerizing track that is a testament to the band’s songwriting and musicianship. Heather Redman’s vocals are hauntingly beautiful, and the Reputation’s arrangement is powerful. This song is a perfect encapsulation of the band’s ability to create music that is both emotionally resonant and musically engaging. The guitar solo in “Broken Bones” is a thing of beauty, showcasing the band’s virtuosity.

As the album approaches the end, the choice of the Amber Hargett penned evocative tune “Prove It To Me” provides a poignant and intimate moment. Redman’s voice is soulful and resolute with a dash of defiance conveying a sense of demand while carrying under the surface hints of closure and acceptance. The Reputation’s acoustic instrumentation in this track is a departure from the rest of the album, showcasing their versatility. It’s a bittersweet clarion call to ‘Prove It To Me‘ that leaves a lasting impression. The drums and percussion on this song from veteran drummer Dan Stahl shine on this song.

Every soulful album should have a passionate plea and Tryin‘ — the penultimate song on the record — is a barn burner that just simply leaves everything on the floor. Heather Redman’s lyrics are a testament to her songwriting abilities. Her words cut to the core of human emotions, exploring themes of love, heartbreak, and self-discovery. The lyrics of this song are thought-provoking and relatable, making it easy for listeners to connect with it on a personal level. Across the eight songs on the entire record, Redman’s storytelling is vivid and evocative, creating a strong emotional resonance that lingers long after the music stops. The listener is left wondering, what happens after the music fades.

The closing track, “The Getdown,” is a fitting end to the album. It’s a triumphant and anthemic song that encapsulates the essence of Heather Redman & The Reputation. The band’s chemistry is on full display, with a powerful, driving rhythm section and searing guitar work. Redman’s vocals are filled with determination and resolve, making it clear that this band has arrived and is here to stay.

Throughout the album, Heather Redman & The Reputation effortlessly blend elements of blues and rock, creating a sound that is both timeless and contemporary. The interplay between Redman’s expressive vocals and the band’s impeccable instrumentation is a match made in musical heaven. This album isn’t just a collection of songs; it’s a narrative journey that takes the listener through the highs and lows of life’s experiences.

The Reputation’s musicianship is equally impressive. The band members are not just skilled instrumentalists; they are true artists who understand the nuances of their craft. Their ability to seamlessly switch between different styles and moods is a testament to their versatility and adaptability. The guitar work, in particular, is a highlight, with solos that are both soulful and electrifying. The organ/keyboards pull a sonic sleight of hand in creating a sway to the songs that add to the bounce and joy of each tune.

Heather Redman & The Reputation’s self-titled album is a triumph in modern rock music because it is so rare for a debut album to smoothly transition across styles and there is no awkwardness or jarring shift, the songs flow as if moving downstream. It’s a rare gem that captures the spirit of classic blues and rock while infusing it with fresh and contemporary energy with a healthy helping of soul. The band’s ability to convey complex emotions through their music is nothing short of remarkable, and Heather Redman’s vocals are a force to be reckoned with. You cannot look away when Heather Redman sings, it’s as if her singing possesses an unrelenting gravitational pull.

In a musical landscape that often prioritizes the trendy and the ephemeral, Heather Redman & The Reputation stand as a testament to the enduring power of authentic and emotionally charged music. This album is a must-listen for anyone who craves music that goes beyond the surface and delves deep into the human experience. Heather Redman & The Reputation have not only made a name for themselves; they’ve etched their reputation into the annals of rock and blues music. This is the band you will want to remember.

So, if you’re in the mood for a musical journey that will move your soul, make sure to give “Heather Redman & The Reputation” a spin. This is an album that demands to be heard and it will not take ‘no’ for an answer. This record will leave a lasting impression and firmly establishes Heather Redman & The Reputation as a force to be reckoned with in the musical spheres of funk, soul, rock, and blues. Don’t miss out on the opportunity to witness their sly musical magic.

Video of The Day: Heather Redman & The Reputation – Wait For Me

This Friday, December 9, 2022, Heather Redman releases her first solo record! This is fantastic news. A rock and roll record with soul, funk, country, and RnB influences, this record is real. In fact, if you were to look up the definition of authentic in the dictionary you would see a picture of this artist. Heather has some of the most impressive vocals that you can imagine. She has energy and more virtuosity than you can shake a stick at — or in other words, we mean it when we say we would listen to her sing the phone book.

Heather Redman has assembled a crack band featuring the rhythm section from Dayton giants Shrug — Dan Stahl (drums) and Bryan Lakatos (bass) and kickin’ guitar from Matt Webster (The Professors, oh let’s be honest far too many bands to mention) and the multi-instrumentalist David Payne (The New Old Fashioned, Midwest Business Machine, not to mention his own stellar solo recordings)! The album was produced by “The Wizard” Patrick Himes, who contributed more than a few sonic touches to this excellent album.

If you add it all up and you have a recipe for music textures that illuminate their influences while adding new musical territory to the map of songcraft called ‘Heather Redman & The Reputation.

To help you get ready for this new record, care of the fine folks at Magnaphone Records, Heather has released a music video for her second advance single “Wait For Me.” From the start of the thrill of the keyboards to the shot of the drum and strum of the bass string followed by Heather’s hairs standing up on your neck vocals, the sway and swirl of this song will capture your heart. But fear not, you can have it back in a little over three minutes.

See you at the album release celebration at The Yellow Cab Tavern this Friday!

11 Questions with… David Payne

101714517_10163801825875154_1076073664824213504_nThere are always those key individuals in any town who give of themselves to help make the music community stronger. David Payne is just such a fixture of the Dayton Music Scene!

Since he arrived with the achingly beautiful solo albums, ‘21‘ in 2009, he has spun a series of tales about life and music. David recognized the vibrancy of the Dayton music scene with an album of cherished covers ‘Dayton, Ohio‘ in 2017. That same year he released another solo record ‘Cheaper than Therapy‘ which spoke to the powerful healing that lies in making music.

David’s latest solo record ‘Orange Glow‘ was released last year. And that is not the half of his musical productivity. With Kent Montgomery, Tom Blackburn and Matt Oliver — The New Old-Fashioned — he released a stellar debut in 2012. Low Down Dirty Summer Nights was released by the band in 2015. And the captivating energy of the band was obvious to the crowds at their shows. In 2018, the band shared their most recent impressive collection of music, Smalltown, Midwest, USA. Of course, a slew of singles and a fantastic shared ep with The Repeating Arms, Hilltops and Highways is also part of the music that David has been involved in creating.

a2100498429_16Most recently he has released an EP of local music covers with his partner Heather Redman called ‘Stay at Home‘. Their two voices glide and slide along as if they have been singing together their entire lives.  Listening to their interpretation of these songs is a joy.

As always we wish to thank David for taking the time to answer these questions! We appreciate his answering these questions for our readers/listeners on YTAA! We cannot say this enough — thanks again for taking the time!

Dr. J: What can you share with us about when and how you started recording your latest record, Stay Home (with Heather Redman)?

David Payne (DP): Well, when the stay at home order went into effect Heather and I both started missing our friends and the Dayton music scene immediately. I had just finished up my first month of running my own sessions at Reel Love Recording Company here in Dayton when this all started and I really wanted to keep working.

So, I gathered the small amount of recording gear I had at home, Heather and I both picked a few of our favorite songs written by our friends, and started recording some covers.

We didn’t think of it as anything other than a fun project that would keep us busy and that our friends might enjoy. The response we’ve gotten has been a totally unexpected and very pleasant surprise!

Dr. J: You have worked closely with Patrick Himes at Reel Love Recording Company here in Dayton, Ohio for several years, what first led to your recording with Patrick? How has that relationship shaped your music?

a3300088116_10DP: Well, The New Old-Fashioned started recording with Patrick back in 2011 or 2012. I had met Patrick back in 2006 and was a big fan of his old band, Flyaway Minion. By the time TNOF was ready to start recording, Patrick had relocated to Nashville and was running the studio down there. I heard he was looking for bands to record and it seemed like a really good fit for what we were doing. I was a big fan of his previous work like the Minion records and Shrug’s Whole Hog For The Macho Jesus to name a couple, so I was excited to get to work with him.

Patrick has helped shaped my music in just about every way you could think of. When I first started going to Flyaway Minion shows, I was 18 and hadn’t been to very many shows at all. Before then my idea of what a modern rock and roll band was we’re bands like Green Day and Weezer. This huge, most likely unobtainable, pipe dream. What Patrick and Flyaway Minion showed me was there were rock stars right here in my home town and that I could make classic records and play killer shows right here in Dayton.

69872267_2877973685565015_8034193719710187520_nThe other most important thing I learned from Patrick is that we can make classic sounding records the way our heroes did. Modern recording is very convenient and while I think that’s mostly a good thing, it’s easy for the romanticism of making records to get lost in the convenience. Everyone has their own way of making records and every way is valid, but the way we make records at Reel Love helps capture all the things I enjoy about making records. I’ve been very fortunate to be able to work with and study under Patrick. He’s taught we almost every thing I know about making records, which has become something I’m very passionate about. I’m forever grateful for that.

Dr. J: Stay Home is a very different record than Orange Glow (your last solo record), how do these records compare? What influenced your work on each of them?

DP: Orange Glow is a very personal record that I made with Patrick at Reel Love and making it was a very cathartic experience. Stay Home was recorded for fun at home on my iPad and is all songs written by our friends. Ha ha!

I’d say personal experience and Willie Nelson we’re probably the two biggest influences on Orange Glow. The pandemic, the subsequent shutdown, and the infinitely inspiring Dayton music scene were what influenced Stay Home.

Dr. J: ‘Outta Town’ addresses forms of self-doubt or concern with a band or a relationship lasting – is that a correct interpretation of some of the lyrics? In addition, if that is correct, did you intend to address overcoming doubt or did the song evolve in that direction over time?

DP: Yeah, I’d say that’s accurate. I wouldn’t say I was trying to address overcoming that doubt as much as I was just trying to express how the doubt made me feel. I guess it just kinda ended up that way do to the reflective, sort of tongue in cheek angle I took when writing it.

Dr. J: How did the song ‘Outta Town’ come together musically for you?

DP: Orange Glow is a pretty heavy record. I was at the tail end of a really difficult period in my life when I was writing those songs. I was reflecting a lot and feeling a little self isolated. I wanted to write a song that still dealt with those feeling but from a hopefully more humorous and lighthearted way. I wanted it to be a brief moment of levity in an otherwise serious record. I think bringing in a bunch of my rowdy friends to sing on it with me helped drive that idea home. We had a blast that day too!

Dr. J: Where do you often derive inspiration to make music?

DP: Of course it can come from anywhere, and often unexpectedly, but I think conversations with people are where I get the most of my inspiration for songwriting. It could be a whole in depth discussion or sometimes just one thing someone said that sticks with me.

a0785063098_10Dr. J: How would you describe the music that you typically create? How has that process evolved or changed over time (especially as you think about your journey from Cheaper than Therapy to Orange Glow to Stay Home)?

DP: That’s a tough question to answer and probably best left to outside perspective, but If I had to describe it, I guess I’d like to think that first and foremost, it’s honest.  As far as the sound goes, I think it sounds a lot like where I’m from. My own personal take on what the Midwest sounds like, I guess.

I don’t know that my process has really changed that much other than I’ve gotten a little better at it, I hope. Although, I do look to outside perspective a lot more these days.

Dr. J: What is next for you musically as a solo artist and as a member of The New Old-Fashioned? How would you describe your thoughts at this point for your next project after Stay Home?

DP: I’m always writing, and although I haven’t found the shut down to be a very creatively inspiring time, I have written a handful of things.

a3987746246_10We’re almost done with the next New Old-Fashioned record which is a companion EP to our last record, Smalltown, Midwest, USA. It’s a couple songs from those sessions and a couple new ones. We’re excited to get it out, whenever it seems appropriate to do so, I guess. Kinda hard to know what to do right now.

As far as solo stuff goes, I tend to plan that out a lot less than I do with the band. That stuff seems to kinda just happen. I’ve got a few things that I’ve written recently that are more personal and I’ve also been working on some more character driven, concept sort of stuff that’s leaning a little more towards traditional country. Anyway, we’ll see what comes of any of that, but I’ve got some wheels turning.

Dr. J: What is your favorite song to perform? What makes it a current favorite in your performances? Do you enjoy Live Streaming?

DP: Favorite song to play with the band is Kid 2000. It’s just got a lot of energy, it’s relevant, and it’s just fun to play. All Over Now, from the first TNOF record is always fun too and has been a staple in our live set for years. It’s one of Kent’s songs, so he sings it and I just get to play Chuck Berry riffs and goof off with Tom and Matt. Ha ha.

Whatever I’ve written most recently is usually my favorite thing to play solo, but a fun one to play from Orange Glow is, What I Mean To You. The finger picking is fun and it’s my only solo song with an actual guitar solo!

I really have enjoyed the live stream stuff I’ve done, but it sure doesn’t beat playing in front of people. I feel like it was fun for a few weeks, but it got kinda old pretty quick, for me at least. The comment sections are always fun on those.

11823081-1143573845671683-4996563248581076865-oDr. J: What is one message you would hope that listeners find in the unique nature of your latest music?

DP: I hope ‘Orange Glow‘ helps someone going through heartbreak know that a lot of people understand what that feels like, that they’re not alone, and that there might just be a little light at the end of the tunnel. When you’re in that space, it’s hard to believe people when they tell you it’s gonna be OK. I think songs that express how you’re feeling can be really helpful in hard times.

With Smalltown, Midwest, USA, the grandest hope would be that it might make someone show a little more empathy for someone who has it harder than them. I suppose a more realistic hope is that people that do work hard to show kindness and empathy, know that they’re not alone and that we stand with them. I like to think that record is ultimately about trying to understand people.

Dr. J: As a musician, how are you adapting to the challenges of the Coronavirus?

As a musician, if I’m being honest, I don’t think I’ve adapted very well at all. I’ve never been very good at digital media or promoting and distributing my music online, for better or worse. Hats off to those who are!  I’ve always enjoyed the classic approach of trying to make records that sound timeless, then playing the songs live in front of people, and hopefully selling enough copies to make the next one. Rinse, repeat. That model was already dated and out the window before the pandemic. It’s kinda just dead right now and who knows when we’ll get it back. That’s the hard part. I have been able to continue to do some work in the studio, although not as much as I’d hoped to being doing this summer. I am optimistic that when the time comes, people will need live music more than ever.

From a personal standpoint though, it’s forced me to slow down, and spend more time with my fiancee and our little girl. Which has been great! We’ve gotten a lot of family time we wouldn’t have had otherwise and I think it’s made me a better partner and Dad.

a2033241784_16My entire identity has been wrapped up in being a musician, performer, and songwriter since the moment I got my first guitar. It’s all I’ve ever wanted to do. So, I guess I’ve been going through a bit of an identity crises trying to figure out who I am outside of music.

I miss playing loud sweaty rock shows and seeing my friends. I can’t wait to get back to that, when it’s safe to do so.

Until, then I’ll just keep holding on tight to my family, writing as much as I can, and enjoying the brief time I do get to spend with friends in small groups. I can’t wait to see everyone at the rock show and give out a bunch of sweaty hugs. I hope everyone takes good care of themselves and each other in the meantime.

Thanks again to Mr. David Payne for answering our questions! All pictures used courtesy of the artist.

David Payne on Bandcamp    The New Old-Fashioned on Bandcamp    TNOF on Twitter

David Payne on Facebook    The New Old-Fashioned on Facebook    Magnaphone Records

your-tuesday-afternoon-alternative-color copy