Every year, like clockwork, the music world implodes into its annual rite of passage: the “Best of” lists. It doesn’t matter whether we need them or not. We could all be listening to something that absolutely shreds, some obscure record that deserves reverence. Still, here we are, obsessing over arbitrary rankings, as if these lists will unlock some divine, objective truth. It is as if, somehow, this tiny, self-appointed cult of critics, bloggers, and tastemakers can distill the whole sprawling mess of 365 days of music into neat little categories that tell you what was really good.
It’s a bit comical, really. These lists are nothing more than trendy cultural currency, an exercise in opinion policing. As if, come December, we all need some authority to tell us what albums we should have liked. Sure, there are some gems in those Top 10s, some records that hit like a lightning bolt, that maybe wouldn’t have been discovered without the almighty guidance of Pitchfork or Rolling Stone. But let’s not kid ourselves – the list itself is a product, a marketing tool, another algorithm feeding on your desire for validation. The music may be real, but the rankings? Please.
Every December, the ritual plays out like a predictable drama: the same predictable indie hits, the same half-baked arguments, the same flavor-of-the-month that gets hyped until the world collectively shrugs and moves on. It’s all just noise. And yet, we devour it like it’s gospel, eagerly waiting for the validation that maybe, just maybe, our choices are “correct.” But here’s the thing: music is personal. These lists? They’re just noise. It’s time we recognize them for what they are: empty, meaningless packaging for a world that’s forgotten how to just listen.
And with all that said, we do an annual show featuring several hours of bands, musicians, songs and albums that impressed the hell out of us. But not going to make some silly rank order, just a bunch of songs that we thought were incredible. So, yeah if this is a bit speaking from both sides of the mouth, so be it.
Our YTAA Faves of 2024 show includes music from many excellent musicians, such as Tamar Berk, Wussy, Palm Ghosts, Nada Surf, Waxahatchee, MJ Lenderman, JD McPherson, Jeremy Porter, Former Champ, Jason Benefield, J. Robins, Dreamjacket, David Payne, Bad Bad Hats, Bike Routes, Brian Wells, The Campbell Apartment, Amy Rigby, The Armoires, Librarians With Hickeys, Bottlecap Mountain, Liv, The Popravinas, The Nautical Theme, Smug Brothers, The Cure, The Reds, Pinks & Purples, The Umbreallas, Nick Kizirnis, Guided By Voices, and The English Beat and The Tragically Hip re-releases.
So, if this is just another end-of-the-year ritual that nobody needs but everybody wants, then maybe it is worthwhile as a way to share some of the music that deserves to be heard.
The holiday season is traditionally accompanied by the familiar sounds of sleigh bells, cheerful choirs, and iconic tunes from well-established artists. However, for those with an inclination towards alternative and independent music, the indie rock genre offers a refreshing twist to the festive soundtrack. On November 21st, Tom Gilliam and I celebrated our 13th annual YTAA Indie Holiday show. We played music from Dolph Chaney, The Popravinas, The Ramones, The Pogues, Darling West, Heather Redman, Fitz and The Tantrums, My Morning Jacket, Van Plating, Olivia Frances, The Surfajettes, Best Coast, Trey Stone and The Ringers, Calexico, Librarians with Hickeys, Debra Devi, Fountains of Wayne, The Decemberists, Joey Ramone, Bad Religion, Heartless Bastards, The Killers, and Dayton’s own Escape Velocity among others over three hours. I wanted to publicly thank Tom Gilliam of the excellent Dayton-based band Ghost Town Silence, for doing this special show with me for over a decade. I wondered what is it about independent music that allows for the creation of exciting new holiday music. So, if you will indulge me as we enter the holiday season, I will delve into the world of indie rock holiday songs, exploring the charm and uniqueness they bring to the season.
Taking a break from tradition can be a healthy and positive experience. Indie rock holiday songs provide a welcome departure from the conventional jingles and carols that dominate the airwaves during the festive season. Unlike the predictability of traditional holiday music, indie rock artists infuse their creativity into the lyrics and melodies, offering a fresh and sometimes irreverent take on the holiday spirit. The departure from traditional sounds allows listeners to experience the season with a new perspective, embracing the diversity that indie rock brings to the table.
One of the hallmarks of indie rock is its ability to convey complex emotions through music, expressing complex emotions — that special sense of being hit “in the feels” can be a moment of self-reflection. While traditional holiday songs often focus on joy and celebration, indie rock holiday tunes explore a broader spectrum of feelings associated with the season. From the melancholic reflections on solitude during the holidays to the bittersweet nostalgia of past celebrations, indie rock captures the multifaceted nature of the holiday experience. Artists like Sufjan Stevens, The Shins, Debra Devi, and Heartless Bastards weave intricate narratives that resonate with those who may find the holiday season to be a mix of joy and introspection. The Decemberists’ reinterpretation of Big Star’s Jesus Christ, from their album 3rd released in 1974, illustrates this approach quite clearly. The band’s official video incorporates the idea of a Yule Log experience into the music video.
Indie rock holiday songs showcase a range of perspectives on the holidays, reflecting the diversity of experiences within the indie rock community. One of the great aspects of alternative and independent music is the opening to diverse perspectives on the holidays. These songs often touch upon themes like non-traditional celebrations, unconventional family dynamics, and the challenges of navigating societal expectations during the festive season. The narratives presented in indie rock holiday songs provide a sense of relatability for listeners who may not find their own experiences mirrored in more mainstream holiday music. The 2016 original holiday song, “I Feel It In My Bones” from The Killers’ alternative holiday album “Don’t Waste Your Wishes” takes a dark, almost sinister interpretation of Santa Claus.
Indie rock, by its very nature, is a genre that thrives on experimentation and innovation. The best characteristic of an independent song is the surprise you discover when you hear it. Dolph Chaney’s excellent “Jingle Bells” set to Van Halen’s “Panama” is a complete surprise as well as a delight! Big Stir Records has released several fantastic indie holiday songs as part of their Yuletide Wave. When applied to holiday music, the willingness to explore and recreate results in a rich tapestry of unique soundscapes in which to capture the seasonal vibe. From the indie alt-country and folk-infused sounds of Trey Stones and The Ringers’ “Santa, Please Bring Me a Guitar” to the rock and roll vibes of The Ramones “Merry Christmas (I Don’t Want to Fight Tonight),” these songs reimagine the sonic landscape of the holidays. The infusion of indie rock elements into holiday music introduces listeners to a sonic experience that goes beyond the traditional, breathing new life into the seasonal soundscape.
Indie rock holiday songs offer a delightful departure from the familiar tunes that dominate the airwaves during the festive season. By expressing complex emotions, presenting diverse perspectives, and exploring unique soundscapes, indie rock artists contribute a distinct flavor to the holiday music repertoire. The unconventional jingles and alternative carols provide an avenue for listeners to connect with the holiday spirit in ways that resonate with the ever-evolving nature of contemporary music. So, this holiday season, consider expanding your playlist to include indie rock gems that bring a touch of creativity and innovation to the festive sounds we hear this time of year.
In the dimly lit corners of Americana, where the roots of rock ‘n’ roll intertwine with the twang of country, emerges The Popravinas—a band that embodies the spirit of a bygone era while injecting it with fresh, irreverent energy. Their latest, “3-Month Situation,” is a rollicking journey through heartache, relationships, and a hell of a good time.
From the first notes, it’s evident that The Popravinas are not here to play it safe. The song kicks off with an infectious jangly guitar that leads to a foot-stomping feel that sets the tone for the wild ride ahead. The gravelly vocals carry the weight of countless complicated romance stories, while the band’s tight instrumentation weaves a sonic tapestry that’s both nostalgic and contemporary. “3-Month Situation” is an unapologetic celebration of the working-class troubadour tradition of honest inspection of relationships. The song pays homage to the trials found in relationships like a mature Springsteen and early Johnny Cash. Appreciation to Eddy Sill for answering our questions!
Dr. J: What can you share with us about when and how you started writing music?
Back around the early 90s, I was part of a rather raucous alternative pop band in Los Angeles called The Mutts. One of the guitar players who was quite a prolific songwriter, heard some raw ideas of mine and encouraged me to start seriously writing songs. Once I started to do so, I saw people responding very positively to those tunes when I sang them onstage. My confidence grew quite quickly, and as time went on, it became a way of life for me.
Dr. J: What first led to your recording music? How do you approach production?
Recording (especially in the past) has always been somewhat of a boring process for me. In recent years, the advancements in digital recording have made it so much more pleasurable, easy, and exciting. I much prefer it as opposed to sitting in a boring studio for hours on end, as we now do much of our recording right in our bedrooms, emailing various takes back and forth to Lead Guitar/Producer John Adair.
Dr. J: ‘3-Month Situation’ is your most recent music, what led to the making of that song? What were the main influences on your recording of this song?
That’s a funny question because it was actually brought on by a woman who is a long-time friend of mine. She fairly recently mentioned that she was in a “three-month situation” with a guy, and it didn’t turn out all that well. I immediately wrote those three words down as a potential song title. The amazing thing is that I was going through some old emails from about seven years ago, and there was an email from her saying that she had just gotten out of a “three-month situation!” When I saw that, I knew I had to run with it, and it’s one of those songs that developed very quickly from that point.
Dr. J: The song ‘3-Month Situation’ captures a remarkable constellation of musical influences. The song seems to have an almost country feel. Is that a correct interpretation? If that is correct, did you intend to create a song that connects to that style? If that is not correct, how would you describe the feeling of the song?
We’ve done a bit of the Alt-Country thing on all four of our past albums, and you will hear that on some of the upcoming tunes (such as 3-Month Situation). Lyrically the song is better served in this style. The original idea was a bit more of a rock-n-roll song, but things can change a bit as different guitar & keyboard parts are created. We have a keyboard player (Bryon Haney) who actually lives in Charleston, SC, and he has added some good textures to the recordings in the past few years. He plays with us when we tour back east, and occasionally he comes out west to join us onstage.
Dr. J: How did the song ‘3-Month Situation’ come together musically for you?
As per our usual workflow, it starts with a very basic, lo-fi recording of whatever lyrics/melodies are drafted and a very basic, maybe one guitar, demo. It’s mainly used to map out the tempo and structure. After we recorded the drum track, we built up the instruments and then recorded the vocals last.
3- Month had a few more layers of instruments but ultimately we stripped some away for some better dynamics and to give it a little more sovereignty from our other tunes.
Dr. J: Where do you often derive inspiration to make music?
It can be literally anywhere. It can be my next-door neighbor or many times it is traveling to faraway places like Europe. Most of it is observations and interpretations of personal and social experiences. Much of the time, humor is essential.
Dr. J: How would you describe the music that you create? How has that process evolved or changed over time (especially as you think about your journey in the last few years)?
It definitely has a combination of “twang and pop.” I used to kind of fight off the California vibe, but as time has gone on, I tend to let that flow if it needs to be in that direction. As a band, we have evolved to be more autonomous in recording our own ideas and instruments which has relieved a lot of the stresses of time and money. The downside is we have less interaction creating all together at once in the same room which can bring some creative advantages.
Dr. J: What is next for you musically? How would you describe your thoughts at this point for your next project or release?
We are looking forward to a new album to be released in the Spring of 2024, possibly sooner. We like to think things through on new material, as opposed to bombarding the market. Each of our albums has its own vibe and sound yet remains in our particular unique style. I believe we offer a truly original sound while sounding extremely familiar to our listeners.
Dr. J: What is your favorite song to perform live? What is your favorite song to perform in general? What makes that song a current favorite in your performances?
That is a tough one. I know our drummer (Steve Markowitz) has a favorite in “Zoom to the Ocean” from our last album, “Goons West.” It has some pretty challenging guitar parts that sound easier than they are to play. People seem to like that one. I really enjoyed playing “3-Month Situation” live for the first time this past weekend… Until I went blank on some of the lyrics… Ha! But sometimes that kind of thing can really get an audience going, as we are the type of band that can have that kind of looseness work for us.
10. What is one message you would hope that listeners find in ‘3-Month Situation’?
Well, I hope that it strikes people musically and they can relate to what it speaks of. I was really impressed when it first came out that you (Art Jipson/Dr. J) tweeted how high the percentage is of people that date, and it all ends within three months. I love that kind of factual feedback!… lol.
Dr. J: As a musician, how are you adapting to the challenges of creating music? What are your biggest challenges in creating music?
Creating music can be easy. Being in a band can take some work. Getting the music heard is almost impossible. There are so many obstacles if you don’t know the right people. We’d like to get some proper management, but until then we will continue on, and conduct our business as usual. Hey! If It was easy, everyone would do it!
We want to extend our sincere gratitude to Eddy and The Popravinas for answering our questions and continuing to make some really excellent music! Click on the links throughout the article to visit their social media or to listen to various songs that were discussed! If any musicians or artists would like to participate in future ’11 Questions with…’ columns, please feel free to email us at drjytaa@gmail.com. All photos and images courtesy of The Popravinas.
Streaming Forward, Powered By The Past - if you love the 80s music, new music, Eurovision, cheesy pop and awesome playlists then let's get this pop party started!
your tuesday afternoon alternative 