Kyle Melton

Amidst the echoing corridors of indie rock, there lies a trove of hidden gems that, despite their immense talent, have managed to elude the mainstream spotlight. Smug Brothers, a band hailing from both Dayton and Columbus, Ohio, has been one of these underappreciated treasures for over two decades. Their latest release, “In The Book of Bad Ideas,” is a testament to their unyielding passion and unwavering commitment to their craft. In this album, they’ve harnessed the raw power of indie rock ‘n’ roll, crafting gritty and honest music that resonates with anyone who has a heartbeat.

“In The Book of Bad Ideas” is not a record that pleads for your attention; it demands it. The record saunters into the room with a vibe that is warm, welcoming, and inviting. The album opens with the sweet swirling, jangly track “Lullaby.” Right from the first note, you’re thrust into a world of jangly guitars and unapologetic vocals — the song is a slide of authenticity. There’s a sense of urgency and swing in this song that sets the tone for the entire album.

Frontman, guitarist, and songwriter, Kyle Melton, is a gifted storyteller who possesses a voice that simultaneously conveys vulnerability and strength. As he sings it’s evident that the lyrics come from a place of honesty, making it easy for the listener to connect with the music on a personal level even when clever wordplay might hide the destination. Sometimes the fun elliptical mystery is more compelling than an obvious statement.

The Smug Brothers have cultivated a sound that’s refreshingly rebellious within the sonics of an indie rock attack — imagine Guided By Voices with a hint of R.E.M., a pinch of Swearing at Motorists at a lo-fi house on the corner. Tracks like “Pattern Caveat” and “Mistaken for Stars” are indie anthems, amplified by the band’s masterful use of distortion and reverb. Guitarists Kyle Melton and Scott Trimble churn out a jangle pattern riff after riff with an infectious intensity that keeps a loose enjoyment. Their synergy is evident, and they create a wall of sound that engulfs the listener.

The rhythm section, comprised of bassist Kyle Sowash and Dayton music legend, drummer Don Thrasher, is the heartbeat of the album. The band’s relentless energy is anchored by their solid groove, which is particularly prominent in tracks like “Mistaken for Stars,” “Let Me Know When It’s Yes,” “Since the First Time I Heard You Laugh” and “Sudden Berlin.” They are the backbone upon which the edifice of Smug Brothers’ sound stands. The percussion, in particular, jumps out on this record set against the chiming, shimmering guitar cadences over which Melton sings with restrained passion — always vulnerable, confident, and reflective.

While the Smug Brothers are unapologetically rocking out, there’s a depth to their music that elevates them above mere noise-makers. The band demonstrates significant emotional depth and nuance across the album’s 15 tracks. “An Age in an Instant,” a melancholic ballad, showcases the band’s ability to slow down and embrace vulnerability without a sneer or nod to fiction. Nothing is pretense, everything matters. The lyrics convey a sense of introspection and longing, accompanied by beautifully understated guitar work that allows Melton’s voice to take center stage. The song works because of the high-intensity songs that come before it, especially “Enceladus Lexicon.”

“In The Book of Bad Ideas” is not just an album about decision-making whether it’s personal choices or the ideas of others. It’s also a meditation on the human condition. In tracks like “Nights in Other Worlds,” the band grapples with themes of regret and longing, painting a poignant picture of the emotional complexities of life. These introspective moments are the yin to the album’s shimmering yang.

One of the most captivating aspects of “In The Book of Bad Ideas” is how it manages to feel both contemporary and nostalgic simultaneously. It’s as if the band has dusted off classic rock’s blueprint and breathed new life into it. You can hear shades of influences from the likes of The Replacements, Guided By Voices, The Beatles, Swearing at Motorists, The Smiths, and even glimpses of the punk sensibility of The Clash. But Smug Brothers don’t merely replicate; they reinterpret, adding their own unique spin.

“Paradise Farms” — the last song on the record — is a standout track that exemplifies this fusion of old and new. The song feels like an homage to rock ‘n’ roll itself lyrically and musically. The song serves as both a tribute and a mission statement. It’s an invitation to rediscover the pure, real, unfiltered spirit of rock music, and the Smug Brothers make a compelling case that the past informs and shapes the present but does not dominate new ideas.

“In The Book of Bad Ideas” is not just a triumph of songwriting and performance but also of production. The album was expertly mixed by Melton, himself, whose experience as a prolific songwriter, guitarist, and singer allows him to bring a wealth of knowledge to the project. Melton has crafted a sonic landscape that’s powerful, vulnerable, and nuanced, allowing the subtleties of each instrument and Melton’s own vocals to shine brightly.

“In The Book of Bad Ideas” is more than an album; it’s a musical odyssey. From the indie rock anthems to the introspective ballads, this record takes you on a rollercoaster ride of emotions. It’s an album that can accompany you during moments of rebellion and introspection, making it an ideal soundtrack for life’s myriad experiences. While Smug Brothers may not be a household name, their music is a testament to the enduring power of indie rock. “In The Book of Bad Ideas” is the culmination of their years of dedication and a reminder that sometimes, the most authentic and heartfelt music can be found off the beaten path.

“In The Book of Bad Ideas” is a testament to the enduring spirit of rock ‘n’ roll. The Smug Brothers have crafted an album that’s equal parts rebellion and introspection, all while paying homage to the roots of the genre. This album isn’t just a collection of songs; it’s a powerful statement that demands to be heard.

In a world saturated with music that often feels manufactured, the Smug Brothers’ authenticity and passion shine through. Their willingness to embrace vulnerability and channel raw energy through a jangle-shimmering prism makes “In The Book of Bad Ideas” a remarkable achievement. So, take a journey with Smug Brothers and immerse yourself in their world. You won’t be disappointed. This album is, quite simply, the book of great ideas.

After a hiatus of a few months, we return with our eighth installment of ’11 Questions with…’ column. We resume these articles with an interview featuring Smug Brothers‘ songwriter, guitarist and singer Kyle Melton. We want to publicly thank Kyle for taking the time to answer these questions!

Smug Brothers have been a prolific and active band without sacrificing quality. The vision for Smug Brothers is reflected in the interests, lyrics and approach that Kyle Melton has crafted for the group. The development of this band parallels the songwriting focus.

Smug Brothers begin in 2005 with the exciting debut record, Buzzmounter. This record featured the driving Valentine Chapel. In the beginning the band’s music was written by Darryl Robbins [The Motel Beds, Overthought Musik‘s numerous side projects] and the vocals and lyrics were created by Kyle Melton. Over time, Smug Brothers transformed into a cohesive band adding several musicians and artists into its indie rock sensibility. The eventual addition of Ex-Guided By Voices and Swearing at Motorists drummer Don Thrasher on drums and percussion and the departure of Darryl Robbins transformed the band. The addition of guitarist Brian Baker [Brat Curse] and then Scott Tribble added sonic texture to the group’s sound. Several talented bass players have participated in this project over the years including Marc Betts, Lurchbox’s Larry Evans and the current bass playing of multi-instrumentalist Kyle Sowash [The Kyle Sowashes]. While additional lineup changes have influenced the sound over the years, the vision for the project has stayed true to an imaginative concept for the most impactful and concise indie pop sound.

The band has been incredibly active from 2005 – 2019, releasing several excellent Midwestern indie rock album including the fantastic On The Way to the Punchline, the powerfully inventive Woodpecker Paradise and the amazingly accessible and catchy, Disco Maroon. In a just musical world (do not hold your breath waiting!), Disco Maroon would have produced top 40 singles with ‘Hang Up’ and ‘My Little Crowd Pleaser.’

In 2019, with the record Attic Harvest the band released its first record on vinyl — which is an important achievement. The group also released Serve A Thirsty Moon in that same year which speaks to their productivity! And to add more fuel to the idea of productivity — in the past challenging year because of the pandemic — the band was still able to release two terrific EPs, Room Of The Year and Every Surface Under Heaven and the single ‘Flame Verbatim.’

Originally formed in Dayton, Ohio and then Smug Brothers HQ relocated to Columbus, Ohio, Smug Brothers have released some of the most catchy, interesting and melodic Midwestern indie rock and roll in… well, the Midwest and beyond.

Dr. J: What can you share with us about when and how you started writing the latest album Room Of The Year?

Kyle Melton (KM): Much of Room of the Year, as well as ‘Flame Verbatim’ and Every Surface Under Heaven, was written between fall 2018 and fall 2019. I was working from home during that year and had a guitar handy a lot of the time. We whittled down a batch of about 100 songs to 30 or so that we liked best, then set to work recording in December 2019 and got the 12 songs that appear on these three EPs before COVID-19 hit and we couldn’t get together to work on any more.

Dr. J: What is your approach in recording? What are your biggest challenges when creating new music? What is the biggest reward for you when making new music

KM: For these three most recent single EPs, we stuck with our tried-and-true method of Don [Thasher] and I getting in a room together and hashing out a rhythm track to build off. With the COVID-19 situation this year, we had to figure out how to get [Kyle] Sowash to record his bass parts from where he is. Scott had done a lot of work from his place and sent it over with Serve A Thirsty Moon, so we had that dialed in. For us, the biggest challenge is making time to get things done. As you get older, there are a lot more obstacles to getting music done than when you’re 25. I think there are levels of rewards: when you know you have a good basic track with a good energy you can build up, when everyone’s parts get added and the picture becomes more complete, when you add the extra touches to flesh it out, when you have a final mix/master that is what is going out. The whole process is still just such a buzz, really.

Dr. J: Freshman Zephyr is a fascinating song. There are some of the classic elements of the band and some exciting experimentation. In particular, for me, the use of electronics/keyboards adds an unexpected dimension to the song. When I expect a guitar part to come into the mix, a keyboard/electronic part does instead. Did you set out to explore a more expansive sonic feel when starting to work on that song?

KM: We’re always trying to figure out how to expand what it is we sound like, so I think Freshman Zephyr is in that lineage a bit. Scott really turned us more toward adding keyboards in a way we didn’t previously, so that’s largely his contribution. We rarely set out to do anything more than whatever the song asks us to do, really. It’s usually pretty obvious if something is going to work for a song or if we need to push out past ourselves to figure out what the song needs. And we typically know when we’ve found something we all like.

Dr. J: Room of The Year seems to address themes of existence apart from the technology that we have become so comfortable using without asking what it means to be so dependent. I am thinking Radiator One, Good To Know Your Axis and Freshman Zephyr lyrically raise questions about technology. Would you say that is accurate? What themes were you addressing?

KM: Sure, there are flashes of coming to terms with technology in a lot of what I write. I think it’s just so prevalent in our current lives, that kind of thinking is going to be part of what I’m talking about. I have a very love/hate relationship with technology, as I’m sure a lot of us do. But I think we’re all working to find where we strike a balance between the benefits and whatever our humanity is. Where is your axis, you know?

Dr. J: How did Freshman Zephyr come together musically for you? How does that compare with Good To Know Your Axis?

KM: I think those songs have very different base identities: Freshman Zephyr is more in the pop house and Good to Know Your Axis is more in the postpunk range. So, from that standpoint, we would work on them with very different ideas in mind; you can’t really do the same kinds of things with both of these songs. We built them up in a similar way, but the four of us have developed a good unspoken language of what different types of songs would ask you to do.

Dr. J: Where do you often derive inspiration to make music?

KM: I always have the itch to make music. The struggle is getting it down on the phone or on tape in a timely fashion. The inspiration is everywhere, really. Listening to what other people are putting out is always inspiring. Going back and digging on things I’ve heard countless times but finding one new nuance, that sets off an idea. Things people say on TV or the Internet or in a text message. All of it has potential to trigger me to get to work.

Dr. J: How would you describe the music that you typically create? How has that process evolved or changed over time (especially as you think about your journey from Attic Harvest to Serve A Thirsty Moon to Flame Verbatim and Room of the Year)?

KM: I have to feel some kind of energy from the connection between the words and music to get things going. I tend to write words and music separately, so when I try and put them together, I’m hoping there is a cool thing that happens. And there’s a big range, so that’s helpful. The biggest thing for how I work and how we’re able to function as group from Attic Harvest up through these new EPs is sharing demos in advance with the group that gives us a better idea of what we can work on and a sketch of an idea. When Don and I started playing together back in 2008, I would just throw a song at him totally cold and we’d come up with something. He has a little more advance idea now, which he says he likes a lot more. I think a lot of how I put songs together is fundamentally the same as I’ve done for a long time: pick up a guitar, throw some words out, and see what comes together. I raise the sails and hope for a strong wind to get us somewhere new and interesting.

Dr. J: What is next for you musically? How would you describe your thoughts at this point for your next project after Room of the Year?

KM: It’s hard to predict what we’ll be able to do in the next year, as COVID-19 doesn’t seem to be going anywhere anytime soon. We have some things we’ve already started working on, so we’ll have to see what we come up with next. I think we’re all game to approach things a little differently, since we’re just not really able to do things the way we normally would.

Dr. J: What is your favorite song to perform? What makes it a current favorite in your
performances?

KM: Well, we didn’t get to do any shows this year, so this isn’t really a current view, but Investigative Years [from On The Way To The Punchline], Reminding Penumbra [from Attic Harvest], and Hang Up [from Disco Maroon] have always been very enjoyable for me. They all have different things going on, but they’re fun to sing and the band typically gets a good headwind going behind each of them.

Dr. J: What is one message you would hope that listeners find in the unique nature of your latest music?

KM: I think there’s a hopefulness in this most recent batch of songs. Always keep looking for new ways to engage yourself and the world. Remain open to possibilities. The world is a lot more than most of us realize. Enjoy the ride, you know?

Dr. J: As a musician, how are you adapting to the challenges of the Coronavirus?

KM: Not playing shows has been a real bummer this year. First year since I started playing in bands in 1992 that I won’t do a single gig. But there’s always time to work on music and I’m grateful the four of us figured out how to work remotely to keep the ball moving. I miss “the Brothers,” but we did a Zoom call recently just to have a hang. That’s what band practice is like in 2020.

You can follow Kyle Melton and Smug Brothers on various social media including:

Facebook Twitter at @smugbrothers Instagram at smugbrothers Spotify Bandcamp YouTube

We want to extend our sincere gratitude to Kyle for answering our questions and continuing to make some really excellent music! Click on the links throughout the article to visit Smug Brothers’s Bandcamp page! If any musicians or artists would like to participate in future ’11 Questions’ columns, please feel free to email us at drjytaa@gmail.com. All photos care of Kyle Melton.