As we celebrate the Ed Stasium remix of The Replacements album ‘Tim‘, we thought gathering other music lovers’ thoughts would be a great way to stop and consider the impact of this record. The fourth ‘Revisit’ comes from our friend, musician, and music writer, Matt Derda of Matt Derda & The High Watts! Matt is a Chicago area-based musician who has released some incredible music. Thank you, Matt!

Recently, I saw a video where someone had a Fender Telecaster guitar and the paint started to wear off. Underneath the black layer of paint was an incredible paisley design. The guitar was perfect already and it played great, but with this discovery, it’s now an amazingly beautiful guitar. I think you get the metaphor here.

I was a huge fan of the Dead Man’s Pop reissue and it felt like a totally new Replacements’ record. I really didn’t have that much of an issue with the original Don’t Tell A Soul like everyone else did, but it was a welcome update. But I actually couldn’t fathom how they could make Tim better. Bastards of Young is already in my top 5 best songs of all time. However, Tim (Let It Bleed Edition) should probably become an adjective to describe something that is old, but yet new at the same time. I don’t know that there is a better example to ever exist.

Every single track is familiar, yet slightly different. I think what stands out the most is how much you can hear the clarity of all of the guitar parts. If you already thought Bob Stinson was a genius guitar player before, well now he’s a guitar god. And really the whole band just played incredibly well off each other. I prefer to listen to live recordings, either bootlegs or official releases. The Tim (Let It Bleed Edition) sounds like a live recording. It’s as if you’re sitting in the room with The Mats as they play all of these tracks together. 

And everything seems to have a little extra swing to it. I don’t think I realized how danceable this record was before. Kiss Me On The Bus was already pretty peppy, but something about being able to hear Bob’s guitar and Tommy’s bass a little better makes me want to get up and dance. Dose of Thunder sounds a little less KISS and more like the Dead Boys. Waitress in the Sky could easily be a hit on Outlaw Country on SiriusXM radio. Bastards of the Young doesn’t sound all that much different, but it didn’t need to. It’s perfect.

A proud parenting moment for me was when my six-year-old asked me what song I was listening to one night while doing the dishes. It was the new Ed Stasium mix of Waitress in the Sky. She said, “I like this song.” I’ve never been prouder.

The stand-out song for me though is Swingin Party. I never really cared for this song. Of course, the lyrics are masterful, per all Westerberg tunes, but I just thought the song was kind of boring. Everyone always loves that song so I was kind of embarrassed that I didn’t care for it. However, on this reissue, it seems like a totally different song. It went from one of my least favorites to one of my favorites. I think it is because you can clearly hear Tommy’s bass lines. The song actually swings now.

Finally, I have always been a huge fan of the song Nowhere is My Home. It’s probably one of my top 10 favorite Mats songs, and it was originally cut from the album! This edition gives us two…TWO versions of Nowhere is My Home. 

All in all…10/10. Would recommend.